1. The terms "vitamin D2" and "vitamin D3" do not refer to the hydroxylation status of vitamin D--either D2 or D3 can exist in the (1,25-OH), (25-OH), and unhydroxylated varieties--rather, they refer to whether or not the vitamin D derives from animal (D3, also called cholecalciferol) or plant (D2, also called ergocalciferol).
2. Ergocalciferol (Vit D2) is the least expensive, is the type of vitamin D with which milk is fortified, and can be given in large enough oral doses to correct vitamin D deficiency relatively rapidly (e.g., 50000 units of ergocalciferol po qweek x 12 weeks).
3. Cholecalciferol (Vit D3) is better absorbed orally than Vit D2, but is not available as a high dose form like D2 (e.g., 400-800 units po qd of cholecalciferol).
4. Calcitriol refers to the activated form of vitamin D, which is hydroxylated at both the (1) and (25) positions, and may be either D2 or D3; the medication calcitriol is the D3 form.
5. Cholecalciferol (VitD3) is produced in the human skin in response to UV light and is initially unhydroxylated at both the (1) and (25) position. Hydroxylation occurs at the (25) position in the liver (an efficient process which generally occurs even in the setting of advanced liver disease) and occurs at the (1) position in the kidney.
6. Paricalcitol (Zemplar) is a vitamin D2 analogue which is hydroxylated at both (1) and (25) positions.
7. doxercalciferol (Hectorol) is another vitamin D2 analogue which is hydroxylated only at the (1) position.
Thanks for explaining! Never knew about the D2/D3 thing. Does a vit D1 exist as well?
ReplyDeleteAccording to my Endocrinology Fellow friend, vitamin D1 is a 1:1 mixture of ergocalciferol (D2) and lumisterol. As best I can tell this was a synthetic "early generation" attempt at supplementing the diet with vitamin D which is no longer used.
ReplyDeleteTheoritically Vitamin D2 or D3 should not be effective in patients with ESRD/CKD as they do not have the 1 hydroxylation. Then how come some PCPs use D2 as a supplement in ESRD patients?
ReplyDeleteHi,
ReplyDeleteNot really related to this topic,but is anyone aware of any evidence out there linking Vitamin d(D2 or D3) to the formation of kidney stones?
Anything other than the WHI study?